There are various ‘Will Kits’ available online – most are cheap or ‘free’ and all you need to do is download them and fill in the blanks. Many websites boast that you can prepare your Will ‘without spending hundreds of dollars on legal fees’.

Simple, right? Not really.

Generating an online Will may seem easy, but the ‘hundreds of dollars’ that you might save will never make up for some of the possible pitfalls in preparing a Will without sound legal advice.

When you generate your own online Will, you don’t meet personally with the writer of the Will. You don’t have the opportunity to discuss your family and your circumstances, and a lawyer does not have the opportunity to identify issues unique to you that could otherwise be addressed with careful planning.

The following are some of the important considerations that an experienced Ontario wills and estates lawyer will address, that a Will Kit may not.

Making sure your Will is valid

Under Ontario’s Succession Law Reform Act, a typed or printed Will must be signed at the end by you in the presence of two witnesses who are present at the same time, and who then sign in your presence. A gift to a witness, or to a witness’s spouse, is generally void. Mistakes in signing are among the most common problems with do-it-yourself Wills. While a court can now validate some defective Wills, that requires a court application, adding cost and delay for your family.

Recent changes also matter: since January 1, 2022, getting married no longer revokes an existing Will, and a separated spouse may be treated as if they had died before you. Many people are unaware of how these rules affect their plans.

An estate plan, not just a Will

A lawyer will take a holistic approach. As well as planning how your assets are distributed when you die, you should plan for incapacity by appointing attorneys under a Continuing Power of Attorney for Property and a Power of Attorney for Personal Care, and, if you have young children, naming who you would like to care for them.

A lawyer will also consider how your assets are held. Property owned jointly with a right of survivorship passes automatically to the surviving owner, regardless of what your Will says. However, where a parent adds an adult child to a bank account or property, the law may presume the child holds it in trust for the estate unless there is clear evidence of a gift. Getting this wrong is a frequent cause of family disputes.

RRSPs, RRIFs, pensions and life insurance

Registered plans, pensions and life insurance with a named beneficiary generally pass directly to that beneficiary, outside your estate. This can save Estate Administration Tax, but it can also create unintended results. For example, the full value of an RRSP or RRIF is usually taxable on your final return unless it passes to a spouse or eligible dependant, so your estate may bear the tax while someone else receives the funds. Your lawyer will coordinate your beneficiary designations with your Will.

Preventing a gift from failing

A common problem with do-it-yourself Wills is the risk that a gift to a beneficiary may fail. ‘Ademption’ occurs when specifically named property in a Will no longer exists at the time the Will-maker dies. Consequently, the intended beneficiary of that gift may lose out altogether, which can be significant where the asset is real estate or a valuable vehicle.

The law has some limited exceptions, but a properly drafted Will can prevent the issue arising in the first place and is likely to avoid unwanted estate disputes.

Protecting your assets and tax planning

Your lawyer will advise on how to structure your Will to protect your assets against distribution to an unintended beneficiary, such as a child’s former spouse or the creditors of a bankrupt beneficiary.

A testamentary trust may be recommended. This is a trust created in your Will that comes into effect after you die, administered by a trustee you choose. For a beneficiary with a disability, a carefully drafted Henson trust can provide for them without affecting their eligibility for the Ontario Disability Support Program (ODSP).

In Ontario, Estate Administration Tax (commonly called probate tax) is charged at 1.5% on the value of an estate above $50,000. Depending on your assets, strategies such as using multiple Wills can lawfully reduce this tax. On death, you are also deemed to have sold your capital property, which can trigger capital gains tax unless the property passes to a spouse or spousal trust.

An online Will Kit is unlikely to consider these matters and, in any event, cannot provide the legal advice necessary to decide what is appropriate in your circumstances.

Guarding against dependant support claims

Under Part V of the Succession Law Reform Act, a ‘dependant’ who was not adequately provided for can apply to the court for support from your estate, even if that is contrary to your Will. Dependants include a spouse (including a common-law spouse), former spouse, child, parent, brother or sister to whom you were providing support, or were legally obliged to provide support, immediately before your death.

In addition, a married spouse may choose to claim an equalization payment under the Family Law Act instead of taking what you leave them in your Will. Your lawyer can identify potential claims and advise how to reduce the likelihood of a dispute.

Conclusion

Planning your estate and having your Will prepared by a lawyer is a smart move. Your lawyer will ensure your Will is valid, correctly signed and protects your assets and your beneficiaries. They will advise how future changes may affect your estate plan and remind you to review your Will when your circumstances change.

Yes, you can prepare a valid Will online. However, there is considerable risk that it will not be tailored to your unique circumstances, may not achieve exactly what you want, and may not take advantage of structures to protect assets and save tax.

Meeting with a lawyer to discuss your estate plans and finalize a well-considered Will that caters to your circumstances is money well spent.

If you or someone you know wants more information or needs help or advice, email us at info@hayescapartner.com.