Following the breakdown of a marriage or common-law relationship, it is common for separated parties to be unsure and therefore anxious about their entitlements and the assets they are likely to keep. This is only natural given that family law is a complicated and emotional area of law which is often poorly understood.

Unfortunately, this is reflected in a great quantity of inaccurate statements often regarded as fact by those in the community.

What “50/50” really means in Ontario

For married spouses, Ontario’s Family Law Act does start from equality, but not in the way most people expect. The law does not divide each house, car or bank account down the middle. Instead, it divides the growth in each spouse’s net worth during the marriage through a process called equalization of net family property.

Each spouse calculates their own “net family property” (NFP). The spouse with the higher NFP pays the other an equalization payment equal to half the difference. Ownership of the assets themselves does not automatically change.

How net family property is calculated

In general terms, each spouse’s NFP is:

  • the value of everything they own on the valuation date (usually the date of separation), including pensions, RRSPs, investments, business interests and their share of jointly-owned property,
  • less their debts and liabilities on that date,
  • less the net value of property they owned on the date of marriage (other than the matrimonial home),
  • less “excluded property”, such as gifts or inheritances received from third parties during the marriage, personal injury damages and life insurance proceeds, provided these can be traced.

Pensions are included at their family law value, and in many cases up to half of that value can be transferred directly out of the plan to the other spouse.

The matrimonial home is treated differently

  • Both spouses have an equal right to live in the matrimonial home, regardless of whose name is on title.
  • Its value cannot be deducted as a date-of-marriage asset, even if one spouse owned it before the wedding. Likewise, if a gift or inheritance was put into the matrimonial home, it generally loses its excluded status.
  • Neither spouse can sell or mortgage the matrimonial home without the other’s consent or a court order.

When the result is not 50/50

A court may award more or less than half the difference where equalization would be unconscionable. This is a high bar, but it can apply, for example, where a spouse recklessly incurred debts, intentionally depleted their assets, failed to disclose debts at the date of marriage, or where the marriage was very short.

Spouses can also change these rules for themselves through a marriage contract or separation agreement, provided it is properly prepared and each party has full financial disclosure and independent legal advice.

Common-law partners are not covered by equalization

Equalization applies only to married spouses. However long they live together, common-law partners in Ontario have no automatic right to share in each other’s property. Each keeps what is in their own name, unless a court finds a claim such as unjust enrichment or a joint family venture. Spousal support, on the other hand, may be available to common-law partners who have lived together for at least three years, or who have a child together in a relationship of some permanence.

Time limits

An equalization claim must generally be started by the earliest of: two years after a divorce, six years after separation, or six months after a spouse’s death. Missing these deadlines can mean losing the claim entirely.

Summary

For married couples, Ontario starts from an equal sharing of the value built up during the marriage, but the details of what is counted, deducted and excluded make every case different. For common-law couples, the starting point is very different.

It is important for anyone considering separating from their spouse, or who has already separated, to obtain independent legal advice from an experienced family lawyer about their entitlements and obligations.

If you would like advice, guidance or assistance about property division following the breakdown of a marriage or relationship, email us at info@hayescapartner.com.